Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Discussion: Anyone else have what seems like way too many devices and/or PCs in the house?

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

    Discussion: Anyone else have what seems like way too many devices and/or PCs in the house?

    Just chit-chat, nothing earth shattering;

    A recent event; I have a rather w-i-d-e house and all kinds of wi-fi devices (TVs, smoke detectors, cameras, thermostats, et al.). Last week one of my old but faithful Asus routers died ( I had 2 in an AI mesh) and man did things get wonky fast! I powered off the bad one and relocated the good one to a better location and everything started working again, BUT the single (and old) router wasn't up to snuff speed or range wise, for all the devices. Plus, being retired from an IT job and generally a computer nerd, there are 5 wired ethernet PCs, and couple laptops - literally, 38 devices plus our phones!

    Since I had to replace something anyway, I went a bit more modern and got a Wifi Mesh system - last years model tho. The "Newest and Best" WiFi 7 version was like $700 but last years WiFi 6 model only $150.

    I was dreading the initial setup but after looking at it sitting in my office for three days, I dove in. Turned out to be rather painless! I was didn't like that I had to use a phone app to initially configure it, but the directions were clear and the app worked well. The only real issue I ran into was configuring my wired PCs and the laptops wifi. I access them all for maintenance using ssh and I find it easier to use fixed IPs for that purpose. The new router used a different subnet than the previous and I decided to stay with it. The best option turned out to be re-configuring all the PCs to use dynamic IPs instead of fixed, then assigning them IPs using the "Address Reservation" feature on the new routers. Once I updated all the hosts files, everything connected properly and I'm back in business with a faster and more flexible network!

    Please Read Me

    #2
    Just chit-chat, nothing serious here ...
    Two reactions to your post today:

    1 38? I have been complaining about how complicated life has become,
    having to maintain everything, including computers/cell phones/tablets, of which we have 12.
    It seems like every time I turn around, there's something to adjust/fix/ask Gemini about.
    38!? That helps me to quit complaining so much here.
    I have a neighbor who has his KitchenAid dishwasher on an app, along with his kitchen lighting.

    2 "I was dreading the initial setup but after looking at it sitting in my office for three days, I dove in."
    It seems that's a common experience! Even among techie guys. Even -- sometimes -- messing with a furnace, plumbing, or weed eater or anything.
    Dreading, putting it off, making it seem bigger than it usually turns out to be.
    But, fact is, once you dive in, everything seems to follow reasonably well.
    And those apps CAN be very useful, even though I use to poo-poo them.

    At first I listed 6 for us, then remembered the T-Mobile G5 router. one HP printer, hearing aids (long story about those),
    two (smart) TVs, and a cellular-based home landline phone (Consumer Cellular).
    An intellectual says a simple thing in a hard way. An artist says a hard thing in a simple way. Charles Bukowski

    Comment


      #3
      " Anyone else have what seems like way too many devices and/or PCs in the house?"

      Is that even remotely possible?
      Slava Ukraini! 🇺🇦
      Windows no longer obstruct my view.
      Using Kubuntu Linux since March 23, 2007.
      "It is a capital mistake to theorize before one has data." - Sherlock Holmes​

      Comment


        #4
        Anyone else have what seems like way too many devices and/or PCs in the house?
        ​
        uhm...no.
        we have 5 phones , 1 tablet , 1 laptop , 1 smart TV and a xbox ...all connected to 1 router lol
        life is simple here
        our fridge is old school , it has a handle that one has to manually open to see what's inside , make a mental note , and manually close it .
        same with our lights , there's like switches build into the walls everywhere , that one has to press for on/off .
        so yea , pretty smooth sailing here
        ▁ ▂ ▄ ▅ ▆ ▇ █ ᄂIПЦX FӨЯ ᄂIFΣ █ ▇ ▆ ▅ ▄ ▂ ▁

        Comment


          #5
          I have been looking at Wifi Mesh systems but the price kept me back. If you are truly happy with "last years" WiFi 6 model, range, connection strength, and speed, I'm sold. All my devices are older and wouldn't take advantage of WiFi 7. All I require is at least 4 ports for the wired PCs and the rest can go wireless. I like dual band so I can put the mobile devices on the busier slower channel. Does your router allow you to set the fixed IPs by device?
          OS: Kubuntu 26.04 LTS
          Desktop: Dell XPS 8900
          GPU: NVIDIA GeForce GTX 745

          Comment


            #6
            Originally posted by Qqmike View Post
            1 38? I have been complaining about how complicated life has become,
            having to maintain everything, including computers/cell phones/tablets, of which we have 12.
            It seems like every time I turn around, there's something to adjust/fix/ask Gemini about.
            38!? That helps me to quit complaining so much here.
            I have a neighbor who has his KitchenAid dishwasher on an app, along with his kitchen lighting.
            ~~~~
            At first I listed 6 for us, then remembered the T-Mobile G5 router. one HP printer, hearing aids (long story about those),
            two (smart) TVs, and a cellular-based home landline phone (Consumer Cellular).
            38 network devices seems crazy, doesn't it? Honestly, I might have missed a few! Let's see...

            TP-Link Mesh and wired network:
            3 Wifi Routers
            1 Switch

            Devices other than PCs or phones:
            6 Nest smoke detectors
            2 Nest thermostats
            6 Tapo exterior cameras
            1 Door lock
            1 Door bell w/camera
            2 Garage door openers
            6 Google displays/speakers
            2 Smart outlets
            3 Ceiling fans
            6 Roku Streambar/TVs
            1 Google interior camera
            1 HP printer/scanner
            2 Cars​
            ---
            39

            Computers:
            2 Office
            1 Server
            1 Raspberry Pi
            1 Guest room
            2 Laptops
            ---
            7

            Other wireless devices:
            2 Tablets
            2 E-readers
            2 Cell Phones
            --
            6

            56: wired or wifi, if you count everything. Holy crap.

            I had totally forgotten about the cars. They have both wifi and cell connections. Several of the computers have wired and wifi but I only use one or the other, so only counted once.

            The crazy thing is I could easily double the amount of network devices if I had installed remote control light switches or bulbs. A lot of the stuff is really nice to be able to remote control like the garage door openers and door lock. Having smoke detector notifications and thermostats that I can control while away is awesome. The 2 smart outlets control the family room lamps that come on and go off in the evenings.

            Thankfully, the vast majority of these things rarely, if ever, need attention. I have no intention of buying a "smart" refrigerator or washer/dryer or any other appliance.
            Last edited by oshunluvr; Today, 12:57 PM.

            Please Read Me

            Comment


              #7
              Originally posted by die.boer View Post
              ​
              uhm...no.
              we have 5 phones , 1 tablet , 1 laptop , 1 smart TV and a xbox ...all connected to 1 router lol
              life is simple here
              our fridge is old school , it has a handle that one has to manually open to see what's inside , make a mental note , and manually close it .
              same with our lights , there's like switches build into the walls everywhere , that one has to press for on/off .
              so yea , pretty smooth sailing here
              I avoid "smart devices". I see no reason for my refrigerator or range to connect to the internet. We only have PCs, mobile devices, and a streaming box connected to an old TV making it act like a "smart TV. I consider a thermostat a gray area because I own mine and the utility provider can't use it to shut me off during peak hours. All of it is connected to one router.
              OS: Kubuntu 26.04 LTS
              Desktop: Dell XPS 8900
              GPU: NVIDIA GeForce GTX 745

              Comment


                #8
                Originally posted by life0riley View Post
                I have been looking at Wifi Mesh systems but the price kept me back. If you are truly happy with "last years" WiFi 6 model, range, connection strength, and speed, I'm sold. All my devices are older and wouldn't take advantage of WiFi 7. All I require is at least 4 ports for the wired PCs and the rest can go wireless. I like dual band so I can put the mobile devices on the busier slower channel. Does your router allow you to set the fixed IPs by device?
                Here's a link to what I ended up buying - the "WiFI 6 Indoor" model. I caught it on a sale for $155. You can see on the page the other options for outdoor and WiFi 7, but like you I didn't need the faster WiFi because nothing I have uses it anyway. The routers I replaced were 10+ years old so anything would be an improvement.

                The one I bought came with 3 "routers" that all have 3 Ethernet ports as well as the wifi. All you really have to do is configure the first one as the "router" and the other two act as "mesh" wifi extensions to the main router. The mesh units either connect via a "backhaul" that can be an Ethernet cable or wireless. Cabled backhauls are much faster then the wireless connection.

                The Ethernet ports work this way: The main router has to be connected to the internet modem directly. Then the other two ports can be backhaul to the mesh routers or to a PC or a network switch. In my case, I wired most of the house years ago so all the PCs and most of the TVs are connected to the switch and so is the wifi main router.

                My setup has the main router in my office where the internet modem and switch are located along with 4 PCs and printer. The main router has a wired backhaul to the other end of the house and that's where the first "Mesh" router is located. The second Mesh router I'm using as a "floater" meaning, a wireless backhaul. It's currently in the family room but I can take it upstairs or onto the deck if needed. It just needs an outlet for power.

                As far as performance, it's better than before but not a huge difference. Sitting near the main router, I get get about 70% upload and 90% download of the full wired speed. Outside and maybe 40-50 feet from the closest wifi router I get about 10-20% of full network speed. None of the wifi devices in the house seem laggy at all and the signal is strong. It a 1GB internet connection.

                And yes you can set "Address Reservations" for devices both wired and wifi. I do this as well. It was easy to sent up. Just leave the device on dynamic mode then on the phone app, select the device (or enter the MAC address) and set the IP address. I had to reboot the computers afterward, but it works well. You can also access the network via the usual way by logging into the main router, but the phone app works well and has a lot more features.

                Please Read Me

                Comment


                  #9
                  Thank you for the link and info! I'm going through the manual for it. I have some design considerations to go through. Maybe I can finally solve the weak signal issue on my patio.
                  OS: Kubuntu 26.04 LTS
                  Desktop: Dell XPS 8900
                  GPU: NVIDIA GeForce GTX 745

                  Comment

                  Users Viewing This Topic

                  Collapse

                  There are 0 users viewing this topic.

                  Working...
                  X